What to say in compensation conversations without over or underpromising | Part 3 of 3

You have a compensation conversation coming up.
You want to reward good work.
You want to be fair.
You also know you can’t open the floodgates or promise something you can’t sustain.
And one wrong sentence can create months of resentment.
In this episode, I walk you through how to talk about pay in a way that reinforces performance, protects expectations, and keeps trust intact.
You’ll learn:
Why mixing compensation updates with performance feedback backfires
How leaders accidentally create unrealistic pay expectations
What your team is actually listening for in money conversations
What to say when raises are smaller than last year
How to handle requests you can’t approve
Ways to reinforce value without committing future dollars
How clear compensation logic reduces turnover
If you’ve ever left a pay conversation replaying everything you said, this episode will give you language you can use right away.
Best for founders, business owners, and managers who want to lead compensation discussions without confusion or fallout.
Download my FREE guide to making hard conversations with your team easier at liagarvin.com/convo
Looking for support for yourself of your team? I've got you covered.
Explore manager training, leaders keynotes & offsites, and 1:1 advisory, or my 90-Day-COO program for business owners who want simple systems that actually work.
I transform teams from cost centers to profit centers with practical tools and research-backed strategies that make managing EASIER.
Get all the details at: www.liagarvin.com
Contact: liagarvin.com/contact
Email: [email protected]
Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lia.garvin
Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@Lia.Garvin
--
© 2026 Lia Garvin / Managing Made Simple